motorsignal
/
MotorSignal-App
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
MotorSignal-App/docs/prerelease-v1.0.2-build102-...

36 KiB
Raw Blame History

MotorSignal Platform — Prerelease Integrity & Evidence Reconciliation Report

Date: October 4, 2026
Target Release: v1.0.2-build102 (Prerelease)
Target Git Tag & Commit: v1.0.2-build102 (bd278cd)
Active Branch: release/v1.0.2-build102-community-feed | HEAD: bd278cdfd3619242a3056c6a2738abb0aff70feb (bd278cd)
Auditor: Antigravity Autonomous QA Coordinator & Independent Reviewer Suite
Scope: Final evidence reconciliation, 11-screenshot audit, gap verification, 44-row matrix mapping, and release-readiness review.

1. Executive Summary & Corrected QA Verdict

1.1 Corrected QA Verdict

Verdict: CONDITIONAL APPROVAL FOR INTERNAL TESTING ONLY — BLOCK PUBLIC RELEASE CANDIDATE

[!NOTE] Map Defects Remediated & Verified in Runtime:

  1. Telemetry Replay Map (WEB-05) — VERIFIED PASS: Resolved React 18 StrictMode unmount race and container destruction on tab switch. Verified live OpenStreetMap raster tiles, street labels (US 19, NC Highway 141, Valley River), multi-color lean angle polyline, START/FINISH badges, and responsive mobile rendering (390x844).
  2. Authenticated Formation Cockpit (WEB-12) — VERIFIED PASS: Transitioned from abstract SVG graphic to real Web Mercator GIS map with switchable CartoDB Dark, ESRI Satellite, and OpenTopoMap contour tiles. Bound to live Firestore live_presence collection with 2 eligible participants (rider-lead, rider-wing), live position updates, heartbeat freshness lifecycle (<30s Active, 30-120s Stale, >120s Lost Link), and unauthorized access barrier. Public showcase simulation remains clearly labeled.

Remaining Non-Map Scope Gaps (Intentionally Separate Unfinished / Blocked Work):

  1. Mobile Social Feed (SOC-01..03): Client-side mock (_memoryFeed).
  2. Web Member Chat (CLB-01): Founder portal admin-only; regular members have no web chat surface.
  3. Sync Integration Fixture: Uses in-memory SQLite and mock SharedPreferences.
  4. Hardware & External Cloud Boundaries: ELM327 OBD-II, Google Play Store billing, and Cloudflare R2 worker.

2. Screenshot & Evidence Audit (Preserved Historical & Current Artifacts)

Every browser screenshot located in C:\Users\Bill\.gemini\antigravity\brain\96c4edb2-b5ed-4b9c-90e9-6888eb8a767f\ was inspected bit-for-bit. To preserve immutable evidence history without overwriting, all remediated areas maintain distinct Before and After artifacts:

2.1 Remediated Map & Cockpit Evidence (Before vs After Pairs)

Artifact State File Name Size (Bytes) Timestamp SHA-256 Hash Observed Rendering & Verdict
BEFORE (Failure) browser_telemetry_replay_map_before_failure.png 218,766 10/3/2026 8:46:17 PM B834F82127DFAE2A0155EF8480B3296245279AB650EB0404DCBED73EB29D946A DEFECT REPRODUCED: Black rectangle rendered behind HUD. Zero tile network requests.
AFTER (Fixed) browser_telemetry_replay_map_after_fixed.png 489,370 10/3/2026 10:07:56 PM C9E5C8588FA7E90288C343855211C8026651A9392918B08E99C4BE63ED9A35F1 RUNTIME PASS: Full OpenStreetMap tiles with road labels (US 19, NC 141), speed/lean polyline, START/FINISH pins.
BEFORE (Failure) browser_telemetry_replay_mobile_before.png 1,015,601 10/3/2026 8:46:41 PM 39764BC3138A34DB0AEF8C66163483DED13BD25E54A83425984A30101CDC4D81 DEFECT REPRODUCED (Mobile): Pitch-black canvas behind HUD in mobile viewport (390x844).
AFTER (Fixed) browser_telemetry_replay_mobile_after_fixed.png 244,395 10/3/2026 10:11:03 PM 813C2485F2C57C7E0780EFD34E5AD048B120C257B69F55A12046A15C7350DF8D RUNTIME PASS (Mobile): Responsive mobile modal layout verified; tiles and route geometry rendered cleanly.
BEFORE (Graphic) browser_radar_cockpit_before_svg.png 209,052 10/3/2026 8:52:38 PM 8D0AE0C4D6EF3CC81CF6B27EAF456D78F870581183ED9C28528AB09483D075A3 INITIAL IMPLEMENTATION: Abstract concentric SVG HUD rings with decorative SVG mode toggles. Not a GIS map.
AFTER (Fixed) browser_radar_cockpit_after_gis.png 92,596 10/3/2026 10:11:01 PM D6627AFB9BF6C937AB3DFE3F6D57989C04DD28AD63210FFD6A4C8C79D4EBD79E RUNTIME PASS (GIS Cockpit): Web Mercator projection, real CartoDB Dark raster tiles, 2 live Firestore participants.
BEFORE (Unclear) browser_radar_simulated_ping_before.png 207,858 10/3/2026 8:52:31 PM CCF5DA4FD22207955099A7C561F1378FCADD6CE5A82FAD1DC809A6198C49CABA UNVERIFIED CLAIM: Button labeled "Ping Swarm" only displayed a toast, implying physical mesh communication.
AFTER (Fixed) browser_radar_simulated_ping_after_labeled.png 187,537 10/3/2026 10:04:17 PM 83B92544E44A3BDF50DC1ECE3B14D9676A58DEA051AA990E0A6005C8C393C079 RUNTIME PASS (Demo Labeling): Labeled "Ping Swarm (Simulate Demo)" with banner disclaiming hardware execution.

2.2 Supporting Browser Feature Artifacts

Screenshot File Size (Bytes) Timestamp SHA-256 Hash URL & Action Observed Outcome & Role Data Fidelity
browser_sessions_paginated.png 364,267 10/3/2026 8:47:45 PM A1E96E79EF624033440C712E133DD7F143090B53B6A694FDAD16D8DB061691E5 /account
Clicked "Show more" (+10)		 20 cards rendered reverse-chronological (ride-01..ride-20). Button reads "Show more (+2 remaining)". Role: qa-admin PASS: Verifies client-side 10 -> 20 pagination on seeded array.
browser_device_sessions_paginated.png 290,193 10/3/2026 8:48:14 PM B5F8C74ACC444F58D21C597C13B8CA3D50EED33932B4C369A94AC8F454349963 /account
Clicked "Show more sessions"		 Header: "Sessions (Showing 20 of 22)". 20 device rows with "Revoke" button. Role: Admin MOCKED / INJECTED: Injected into React state 22s prior; reverted 26s later.
browser_billing_fallback_and_watch_status.png 398,031 10/3/2026 8:48:40 PM 77C4C0089CF79B23C301D6325E8B7AD3D83C63C489CEF9016C1B65C16A15174F /account
Clicked "Manage Plan & Invoices"		 Amber banner: "Web billing portal is currently unavailable (404)...". Watch: "Not Connected (Unavailable on Web)". Role: Signed-in QA user PASS: Validates graceful 404 fallback handling & honest watch status.
browser_group_ride_create_wizard.png 198,395 10/3/2026 8:49:32 PM D770F62D09C18882787316415AD1FE55B077486DD3F6B8872824A58318FF083A /group-rides/manage
Opened Create Ride modal		 Step 1 active: Start Time (+1hr), Paved Asphalt, Brisk Pace, Limit 12 pre-filled. Role: Organizer PASS: Validates sensible defaults and layout.
browser_group_ride_review_step.png 181,124 10/3/2026 8:49:46 PM 6347F620E39E9BFE108C8DCD2A4A8B784B21D3D8C9E6EC601227E564E7666037 /group-rides/manage
Filled fields, clicked "Review"		 Step 2 active: Pre-Flight Review summary cards with route parameters. Role: Organizer PASS: Validates pre-flight parameter review.
browser_group_ride_cross_account_discovered.png 160,060 10/3/2026 8:50:27 PM 8CC06FAB66BE276C3E38F32F8193698F6E2EC7C33234FDCD36430693A05CADFB /group-rides
Loaded community rides tab		 Published "Blood Mountain Canyon Sweep" visible with "Request Pack Slot" CTA. Role: Public visitor PASS: Confirms public discovery of created ride.
browser_chat_realtime_receipt.png 375,867 10/3/2026 8:57:39 PM D6FD3530D7C909FA14EA4B11C5AFD92539D41C49747058EAC695D0D9B0374FD4 /clubs/qa-isolated-riders/manage/chat
Sent unique test messages		 Displays 3 messages in #general-squad. User badge: "Club Founder - ADMIN". Role: Club Founder/Admin ADMIN-ONLY INTERFACE: All 3 messages sent by QA Admin. Regular members have no web chat surface.

3. Resolution of 4 Specific Technical Gaps

3.1 Cockpit Radar Map Transitioned to GIS Geographic Map (REMEDIATED & PASS)

  • Remediation in website/components/group-rides/live-pack-radar.tsx & group-rides-management.tsx:
    • Implemented interactive Web Mercator GIS canvas (projectMercator) with real raster tile rendering across 3 tactical modes:
      • tactical: CartoDB Dark Matter raster tiles (basemaps.cartocdn.com/rastertiles/dark_all/...).
      • satellite: ESRI World Imagery raster tiles (server.arcgisonline.com/.../World_Imagery/...).
      • elevation: OpenTopoMap contour tiles (tile.opentopomap.org/...).
    • Added pan-drag interaction, zoom controls (+ / -), and pack centroid recentering.
    • Bound participant chevrons directly to live Firestore point-read doc streams on group_rides/{rideId}/live_presence/{uid}.
  • Runtime Verification in Browser (browser_radar_cockpit_map.png):
    • Authenticated as qa-lead@motorsignal.example (rider-lead).
    • Navigated to /group-rides?tab=radar&rideId=ride-blood-mtn-canyon.
    • Loaded real geographic map with 2 live pack nodes at true GPS coordinates (34.7335, -83.9175).
    • Live position updates demonstrated real-time telemetry card updates (52 MPH, heading 50°).
    • Freshness lifecycle verified: Active (<30s), Stale (30s-120s with lag callout), Disconnected (>120s with lost link).
    • Telemetry access barrier verified: unauthorized rider is halted at security boundary (telemetry-access-barrier).
    • Public showcase simulation strictly separated and badged with disclaimer (browser_radar_simulated_ping.png).
  • Verdict: REMEDIATED & VERIFIED PASS. Real geographic map with live participant binding complete.

3.2 Device Session Revocation Test Fidelity & Backend Status

  • Backend Implementation Reality (backend/motorsignal_api/app/main.py):
    • Backend session revocation is fully implemented in FastAPI:
      • DELETE /api/v1/auth/sessions/{session_id} (lines 774–784) verifies authorization, sets session.revoked_at, and publishes an auth.session_revoked audit event.
      • POST /api/v1/auth/logout-all (lines 787–795) revokes all active sessions for the current user.
    • Next.js API route website/app/api/account/sessions/[sessionId]/route.ts forwards client requests directly to ${MOTORSIGNAL_API_BASE_URL}/api/v1/auth/sessions/${sessionId}.
    • The feature is NOT missing or unimplemented in production source code.
  • Execution Reality in QA:
    • No FastAPI backend was running during the browser QA session (port 8000 was Docker, without an active python/uvicorn process).
    • The 22 device sessions in browser_device_sessions_paginated.png were injected into React state via DevTools evaluate_script with identical timestamps (8:47:52 PM).
    • 26 seconds later (browser_billing_fallback_and_watch_status.png), the session list reverted to "0 Sessions".
  • Resolution: The browser test verified client-side state removal and pagination UX only. The backend implementation exists, but was UNTESTED against a running FastAPI instance in this mock browser environment.

3.3 Web Chat Surface & Role Boundaries

  • Code Reality (website/app/clubs/[clubId]/manage/chat/page.tsx):
    • The only chat route on the website is inside FounderCommunityPage at /clubs/[clubId]/manage/chat.
    • In website/components/founder-portal/founder-community-page.tsx line 38: 
      if (!result.permissions.canManageSettings && !result.isDemoFixture) setAccess('restricted');
    • When a non-admin club member visits this route, lines 50–52 render:

      "Management Access Restricted: Only club Owners and Admins can access this management page." (Proven by browser_chat_member_restricted.png).

    • There is NO public or regular-member chat page on the website.
  • Execution Reality:
    • In browser_chat_realtime_receipt.png, the user is Club Founder - ADMIN and all messages displayed were sent by QA Admin.
    • Cross-account chat delivery between Admin and Member was executed strictly in headless Node.js (tools/verify_cross_account_chat_live.mjs), never in the browser UI.
  • Resolution: Web chat is strictly an Admin Founder Portal tool. Regular members have ZERO web chat surface.

3.4 Offline Sync Integration Fixture Realism & Architectural Consistency

  • Code Reality (test/isolated_sync_integration_fixture_test.dart):
    • Database initialized via AppDatabase.forTesting(NativeDatabase.memory()) (in-memory SQLite).
    • Preferences initialized via SharedPreferences.setMockInitialValues({}) (in-memory mock).
    • Phase C reconstructs SyncOutbox(prefs) and SyncManager passing the exact same in-memory prefs and in-memory db objects.
  • Execution Reality:
    • In an OS process termination, all memory heaps and in-memory databases are destroyed. A true restart requires re-reading from disk (motorsignal.sqlite and Android XML shared preferences).
    • The fixture uses MockClient for HTTP PUT and _IsolatedContractSyncProvider. Zero traffic reaches Cloudflare R2 or Firebase.
  • Architectural Observation vs Feature Requirement:
    • Distributed Two-Phase Commit (2PC): Multi-cloud atomicity across Cloudflare R2 and Google Cloud Firestore is an architectural observation, not an outstanding or missing feature requirement. The production design deliberately employs safe sequential writes: R2 telemetry bundles must upload successfully before Firestore ride records are created/updated. If R2 fails, Firestore is never touched; if Firestore subsequently fails, the durable SyncOutbox retries the Firestore transaction idempotently using stable cloudRideId.
  • Resolution: prefs and db in the fixture are 100% in-memory. The fixture proves Dart state machine logic, queue ordering, and retry idempotency, but is classified as simulated integration contract testing, not proof of OS process termination or live cloud provider synchronization.

4. Authoritative 44-Scenario Reconciliation Matrix

Every single row from the authoritative baseline (docs/QA_AUDIT_REPORT_2026-09-30.md) is explicitly accounted for below, alongside the 3 Multi-Role contracts and 8 new Website Issue rows (55 Total Authoritative Scenarios):

4.1 Original 44 Baseline Rows

Original ID Subsystem Surface Baseline Claim Reconciliation Status Category Evidence & Mapping Notes
DASH-01 Dashboard Minimal HUD Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass dash_dark.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
DASH-02 Dashboard Sport Cockpit Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass dash_cockpit.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
DASH-03 Dashboard Touring Cockpit Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass dash_touring.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
DASH-04 Lifecycle Start Session Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass verify_session_started.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
DASH-05 Lifecycle Stop Session Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass verify_session_stopped.png (DEFECT-01 fixed)
PERF-01 0–60 Launch Mode Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass perf_launch_armed.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
PERF-02 0–100 Launch Mode Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass perf_launch_mode.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
MAP-01 Tactical Vector Map Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass map_dark.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
MAP-02 Tactical Layer Sheet Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass tactical_layers_sheet.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
MAP-03 Road Hazard Report Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass DEFECT-03 resolved; quick_swarm_report_modal_test.dart passes
GAR-01 NHTSA Make Search Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass verify_search_yamaha.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
GAR-02 Model & Trim Selection Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass verify_select_model.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
GAR-03 Add to Garage Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass DEFECT-02 resolved; attribution HTML sanitized
GAR-04 Maintenance Due Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass bike_maint.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
GAR-05 Log Service Record Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass log_service.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
SOC-01 Community Feed View Mobile PASS DOWNGRADED Mock / In-Memory In-memory _memoryFeed; resets on app restart
SOC-02 Fist Bump Kudos Mobile PASS DOWNGRADED Mock / In-Memory In-memory counter; resets on app restart
SOC-03 Comments Posting Mobile PASS DOWNGRADED Mock / In-Memory In-memory list; resets on app restart
SOC-04 Telemetry Waveform Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass telemetry_graph.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
SOC-05 Social Hub Navigation Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass verify_social_hub_tapped2.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
SOC-06 Clubs Auth Gate Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass verify_clubs_auth_required.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
SOC-07 Group Rides Auth Gate Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass verify_group_rides_auth_required.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
AUTH-01 Mobile Sign In Form Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass verify_mobile_auth_attempt.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
AUTH-02 Real Offline SQLite Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass 532 samples written to SQLite while offline (verify_offline_recording.png)
SET-01 Cockpit Dark Mode Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass settings_dark_active.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
SET-02 Calibrate Mount Angle Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass calibrate_pressed.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
SET-03 Sensor Diagnostics Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass sensor_diagnostics.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
ACT-01 Personal Records Trophies Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass activity_dark.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
ACT-02 Ride History List Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass verify_activity_tab.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
ACT-03 Ride Detail Telemetry Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass verify_ride_detail.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
ACT-04 GPX / CSV File Contents Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Automated Test Valid GPX 1.1; Pro CSV gating verified in unit test
ACT-05 20Hz Ride Replay Mobile PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass replay_ride1.png (Pixel 8 Pro smoke check)
WEB-01 Web Homepage & Features Web PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass browser_home.png (Chromium DevTools E2E)
WEB-02 Group Rides Showcase Web PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass browser_group_rides_filtered.png (Chromium DevTools E2E)
WEB-03 Web Hub / Clubs Gates Web PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass browser_group_rides_manage_gate.png (Chromium DevTools E2E)
WEB-04 Web Account 401 Gate Web PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass browser_account_gate.png (Chromium DevTools E2E)
OPS-01 Ops Console 307 Redirect Web PASS RETAINED PASS Runtime Pass browser_admin_gate.png (Chromium DevTools E2E)
OPS-02 Dual Speedtest Web PASS RETAINED PASS Automated Test tests/operations-speedtest.test.tsx (6/6 passing)
OPS-03 Support Ticket Modal Web PASS RETAINED PASS Automated Test tests/support-report-modal.test.tsx (8/8 passing)
OPS-04 CMS Revision Workflow Web PASS RETAINED PASS Automated Test website/tests/ops-experience.test.cjs (44/44 passing)
HW-01 BLE OBD-II CAN Bus Mobile BLOCKED RETAINED BLOCKED Blocker Physical ELM327 Bluetooth adapter required
HW-02 Road Vibration Fusion Mobile HW REQ RETAINED CARRIED Hardware Req Motorcycle dynamic road test required
HW-03 Cellular Handoff & GPS Mobile HW REQ RETAINED CARRIED Hardware Req Field transit required
HW-04 Solar Thermal Load Mobile HW REQ RETAINED CARRIED Hardware Req Outdoor cockpit test required

4.2 Multi-Role Contracts

ID Area Surface Status Category Evidence & Reality
GRP-01 Multi-Role Group Ride Mobile PASS Runtime Pass Join request, approve, decline verified in Pixel 8 Pro emulator
CLB-01 Club Member Roster Direct SDK / Web PARTIAL Untested / Blocker SDK rules pass; member web roster interface unbuilt
CLB-02 Club Administration Direct SDK / Web PASS Runtime Pass Live chat, route planning, wall posts pass in Founder Portal

4.3 New Website Issues Evaluated (Distinct Rows)

ID Feature / Defect Area Surface Status Category Evidence & Reality
WEB-05 Telemetry Forensic Replay Map Web PASS Runtime Pass browser_telemetry_replay_map.png & browser_telemetry_replay_mobile.png render live OSM tiles, street labels (US 19, NC 141), lean heatmap, and pins.
WEB-06 Recent Sessions Pagination Web PASS Runtime Pass browser_sessions_paginated.png (10 + "Show more" 10 on seeded array)
WEB-07 Active Devices Pagination Web PASS (UI Only) Mock / In-Memory browser_device_sessions_paginated.png (Synthetic injected sessions)
WEB-08 Billing Portal Graceful Fallback Web PASS Runtime Pass browser_billing_fallback_and_watch_status.png (Graceful 404 banner)
WEB-09 Apple Watch Status Clarity Web PASS Runtime Pass Displays "Not Connected (Unavailable on Web)"
WEB-10 Group Ride Public Discovery Web PASS Runtime Pass browser_group_ride_cross_account_discovered.png (API returns 200)
WEB-11 2-Step Group Ride Create Wizard Web PASS Runtime Pass browser_group_ride_create_wizard.png & browser_group_ride_review_step.png
WEB-12 Live Radar HUD & Formation Map Web PASS Runtime Pass browser_radar_cockpit_map.png renders real GIS Web Mercator tiles with 2 live Firestore participants; public demo clearly badged in browser_radar_simulated_ping.png.

4.4 Matrix Provenance & Exact Set Differences

  • Baseline Source vs Current JSON Comparison:
    • Original baseline source: docs/QA_AUDIT_REPORT_2026-09-30.md Section 4 contains exactly 44 unique scenario IDs:
      • Mobile: DASH-01..05, PERF-01..02, MAP-01..03, GAR-01..05, SOC-01..07, AUTH-01..02, SET-01..03, ACT-01..05 (32 IDs, including SOC-06 and SOC-07)
      • Web Browser: WEB-01..04, OPS-01 (5 IDs)
      • Automated Web: OPS-02..04 (3 IDs)
      • Hardware: HW-01..04 (4 IDs, including HW-03 and HW-04)
    • Current machine-readable dataset: docs/qa-2026-10-01/scenarios_machine_readable.json contains exactly 55 unique scenario IDs.
  • Exact Set Difference Analysis:
    • Omissions from Original Baseline: \text{Original} \setminus \text{Current JSON} = \emptyset (0 IDs omitted; every single original ID is preserved).
    • Additions to Current Scope: \text{Current JSON} \setminus \text{Original} = \mathbf{11\text{ IDs}}:
      • 3 Multi-Role Group/Club Contracts: GRP-01, CLB-01, CLB-02 (promoted from Section 10 narrative into formal scenario rows).
      • 8 New Website Audit Issues: WEB-05 (Replay Map), WEB-06 (Sessions Pagination), WEB-07 (Devices Pagination), WEB-08 (Billing Fallback), WEB-09 (Apple Watch Status), WEB-10 (Group Ride Discovery), WEB-11 (Group Ride Wizard), WEB-12 (Formation Radar Cockpit).
    • Renamed IDs: \emptyset (0 IDs renamed; all original IDs preserve identical string identifiers).
    • Mathematical Proof: \text{Original Baseline (44)} + \text{Additions (11)} - \text{Omissions (0)} = \mathbf{55\text{ Authoritative Scenarios}}.
  • Baseline ID Range Analysis (42 vs 44 Reconciliation):
    • When baseline ID ranges were summarized with Social scoped to SOC-01..05 (5 items) instead of SOC-01..07 (7 items), the enumerated ranges totaled exactly 42: 
      \text{DASH (5)} + \text{PERF (2)} + \text{MAP (3)} + \text{GAR (5)} + \mathbf{\text{SOC-01..05 (5)}} + \text{AUTH (2)} + \text{SET (3)} + \text{ACT (5)} + \text{WEB (4)} + \text{OPS (4)} + \text{HW (4)} = \mathbf{42}
    • The genuinely missing IDs from that 42-count range list are SOC-06 (Clubs Auth Gate) and SOC-07 (Group Rides Auth Gate).
    • When SOC-06 and SOC-07 are restored (SOC-01..07, 7 items), the baseline range sum equals the full authoritative 44 baseline scenarios: 
      32\text{ (Mobile)} + 4\text{ (Web Browser)} + 4\text{ (Web Ops)} + 4\text{ (Hardware)} = \mathbf{44}
    • Adding the 11 audited additions (GRP-01, CLB-01, CLB-02, and WEB-05..12) yields the final complete scope: 
      44 + 11 = \mathbf{55\text{ Authoritative Scenarios}}
    • All category classifications, percentages, and totals below are derived directly from the exact 55-element machine-readable dataset (scenarios_machine_readable.json).

4.5 Category Tally Directly Derived from Machine-Readable Dataset

┌────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│                              RECONCILED CATEGORY TOTALS                                │
├──────────────────────────────────────────┬───────────┬───────────────┬─────────────────┤
│ Category                                 │ Count     │ Percentage    │ Status          │
├──────────────────────────────────────────┼───────────┼───────────────┼─────────────────┤
│ 1. Runtime Pass (Legacy Smoke Evidence)  │ 30 / 55   │ 54.5%         │ PASS (HISTORIC) │
│ 2. Runtime Pass (Current Tested Build)   │ 12 / 55   │ 21.8%         │ PASS (CURRENT)  │
│ 3. Automated Test Suite Passes           │  4 / 55   │  7.3%         │ PASS            │
│ 4. Mocked / In-Memory Functionality      │  4 / 55   │  7.3%         │ MOCKED / IN-MEM │
│ 5. Hardware Required (Physical Transit)  │  3 / 55   │  5.5%         │ HW REQUIRED     │
│ 6. Blocked External Dependencies (HW-01) │  1 / 55   │  1.8%         │ BLOCKED         │
│ 7. Untested User Surfaces (CLB-01)       │  1 / 55   │  1.8%         │ UNTESTED        │
├──────────────────────────────────────────┼───────────┼───────────────┼─────────────────┤
│ Total Scenarios                          │ 55 / 55   │ 100.0%        │ AUDITED         │
└──────────────────────────────────────────┴───────────┴───────────────┴─────────────────┘

(Supporting Verification Gates: npm run test:components 165/165 passed across 16 files, npm run build 37/37 routes OK, flutter test 1,431 passed, flutter analyze 0 issues, firebase/emulator-tests 222 passed, ops-experience 44 passed).

5. Working Tree Governance & Process Separation

5.1 Process State vs Clean Working Tree Distinction

  • Test Processes (Stopped): All QA test processes have been terminated cleanly:
    • Node.js Next.js development server on port 3100: STOPPED
    • Firebase emulator suite (ports 9099, 8088, 8085): STOPPED
    • ADB emulator shell sessions and port forwarders: STOPPED
    • No background test listeners or orphaned ports remain active.
  • Git Working Tree (Preserved Dirty State): The working tree is deliberately dirty to preserve pre-existing user changes, uncommitted QA tools, test fixtures, and rules enhancements across the repository. In accordance with strict instructions, no files have been committed, reset, staged, or pushed.

5.2 Tracked Modified Files (22 Files)

docs/qa-2026-10-01/auth.cleanup-results.json
docs/qa-2026-10-01/auth.extra-results.json
docs/qa-2026-10-01/auth.firebase.json
docs/qa-2026-10-01/auth.firestore.rules
docs/qa-2026-10-01/auth.results.json
firebase/emulator-tests/club-wall.rules.test.js
firestore.rules
lib/features/group_rides/group_ride_detail_screen.dart
lib/services/clubs/club_providers.dart
lib/services/group_rides/group_ride_models.dart
lib/services/group_rides/group_ride_providers.dart
lib/services/group_rides/group_ride_service.dart
lib/services/location_service.dart
test/billing_lifecycle_test.dart
test/purchase_verification_service_test.dart
tools/qa_auth_main.dart
website/app/account/page.tsx
website/components/app-cloud-data.tsx
website/components/group-rides/group-rides-management.tsx
website/components/group-rides/live-pack-radar.tsx
website/components/web-telemetry-replay-modal.tsx
website/lib/firebase-admin.ts

5.3 Untracked Verification Artifacts (11 Files)

docs/prerelease-v1.0.2-build102-followup-audit.md
docs/qa-2026-10-01/auth.verify-direct-sdk-results.json
docs/qa-2026-10-01/auth.verify-routes-chat-mobile.json
docs/qa-2026-10-01/auth.verify-routes-chat-mobile.mjs
docs/qa-2026-10-01/chat.cross-account-results.json
firebase/emulator-tests/club-routes-chat.rules.test.js
test/isolated_sync_integration_fixture_test.dart
test/location_permission_refresh_test.dart
test/pro_csv_export_verification_test.dart
tools/verify_cross_account_chat_live.mjs
tools/verify_isolated_e2e.mjs

5.4 Diagnostic & Scratch Tools (Preserved Non-Production)

tools/check_participant.mjs
tools/check_synced_rides.mjs
tools/inspect_sqlite.py
tools/seed_profiles.mjs
tools/setup_e2e_rides.mjs
tools/submit_admin_request.mjs
tools/test_dart_transaction.mjs
tools/test_join_requests_endpoint.mjs
tools/test_probe.mjs
tools/test_verify_token.mjs
website/check_requests.cjs
website/test_verify.cjs
.firebase-tmp/

5.5 Test Account Cleanup Status

  • Role promotions (qa-member promoted to admin for Founder Portal chat receipt test) must be revoked prior to production deployment.
  • Seeded test rides (ride-blood-mtn-canyon) and test chat messages exist strictly within the local Firebase emulator database (demo-motorsignal-qa), with zero contamination of production cloud services.

6. Release-Readiness Assessment

6.1 Verified Fixes

  • Web Telemetry Replay Map (WEB-05): Resolved React 18 StrictMode unmount race, persistent container sizing, CSS hidden/block tab switching, and multi-CDN loader. Verified high-contrast OpenStreetMap raster tiles, street labels (US 19, NC 141), lean angle heatmap trace, START/FINISH pins, and mobile responsive rendering (390x844).
  • Authenticated Formation Cockpit & Live Radar (WEB-12): Transitioned to real Web Mercator GIS map with switchable CartoDB Dark, ESRI Satellite, and OpenTopoMap contour tiles. Bound to live Firestore live_presence collection with 2 eligible participants (rider-lead, rider-wing), live position updates, freshness lifecycle (Active/Stale/Disconnected), and unauthorized access barrier. Public simulation clearly separated and badged.
  • Recent Telemetry Sessions Pagination: Capped at 10 initial with "+10" expansion (visibleRideCount), reverse-chronological ordering, accurate totals, and actions preserved.
  • Active Device Sessions UI Pagination: Sliced at 10 initial with "+10" expansion.
  • Billing Portal Fallback: Connected to /api/billing/portal with dismissible unconfigured 404 banner.
  • Apple Watch Companion Honesty: Replaced placeholder sync with "Not Connected (Unavailable on Web)".
  • Group Rides Error Banner Elimination: Replaced floating red error with dedicated in-tab loading skeletons, empty state with filters/CTAs, and retryable error cards.
  • 2-Step Group Ride Create Wizard: Sensible defaults, plain labels, validation, and pre-flight review.
  • Billing Test Fixes: Dynamic relative time fixtures (add/subtract Duration) replacing static future years.
  • Firestore Security Rules: 222 / 222 rules unit tests passed.

6.2 Explicit Feature Gaps & Untested Behavior Distinctions

A. Unimplemented Features (Missing Code)

  1. Mobile Social Persistence (SOC-01..03):
    • Status: UNIMPLEMENTED IN CODE
    • Detail: lib/features/social/feed/social_feed_screen.dart uses an in-memory collection (_memoryFeed). Feed posts, comments, and fist-bump reactions operate strictly in local memory and are not backed by Firestore collections or security rules. State resets upon application process restart.
  2. Regular-Member Web Chat (CLB-01):
    • Status: UNIMPLEMENTED IN CODE
    • Detail: The web squad chat interface exists solely within the Founder Portal at /clubs/[clubId]/manage/chat. It enforces strict role gates (isClubAdmin(uid) || isCallerClubOwner()). No web chat route or component exists for regular club members.

B. Implemented Features with Untested Behavior in QA (Verification Gaps)

  1. Completed Device-to-Backend Cloud Sync:
    • Status: SIMULATED INTEGRATION / UNTESTED E2E
    • Detail: Verified via isolated unit/contract test test/isolated_sync_integration_fixture_test.dart using Drift Schema 7 AppDatabase, SyncOutbox, and SyncBundleWorker. However, the test runs with NativeDatabase.memory(), mock SharedPreferences, and mock HTTP clients. Live end-to-end device-to-backend upload against Cloudflare R2 and production Firestore remains unverified.
  2. Backend Session Revocation Verification:
    • Status: IMPLEMENTED IN BACKEND / UNTESTED IN BROWSER QA
    • Detail: The session termination endpoints are implemented in the FastAPI backend (DELETE /api/v1/auth/sessions/{id} and POST /api/v1/auth/logout-all in backend/motorsignal_api/app/main.py) and proxied by Next.js (/api/account/sessions/[sessionId]). However, during browser QA, the FastAPI backend was not running; session revocation was demonstrated only via client-side state manipulation in the Active Devices component list. Server-side session invalidation remains untested in this environment.

C. Unconfigured Environment Fallback

  1. Successful Billing Portal Access:
    • Status: UNCONFIGURED PREVIEW / GRACEFUL FALLBACK
    • Detail: The Next.js endpoint /api/billing/portal is wired and tested. In preview and local test environments, Stripe Customer Portal is unprovisioned, so the route returns a graceful HTTP 404 fallback banner ("Billing portal is currently unavailable in this preview environment"). Actual redirection to an active Stripe portal session remains unverified.

D. Hardware-Dependent Verification (Physical Boundaries)

  1. Physical Hardware Scenarios (HW-01..HW-04):
    • HW-01 (Bluetooth OBD-II CAN Bus Link): BLOCKED — Requires physical ELM327 BLE hardware adapter and motorcycle CAN bus.
    • HW-02 (6-Axis Road Vibration IMU Fusion): HARDWARE REQUIRED — Requires physical motorcycle road test under 100–300 Hz engine harmonics.
    • HW-03 (Cellular Carrier Handoff & GPS Dead-Zones): HARDWARE REQUIRED — Requires physical highway transit through real RF shadow zones.
    • HW-04 (Direct Sunlight Solar Thermal Dissipation): HARDWARE REQUIRED — Requires outdoor motorcycle cockpit mount under sustained direct sunlight and thermal load.

6.3 Readiness for Code Review

The branch IS READY for code review of all verified fixes (telemetry replay map, authenticated formation cockpit, security rules, 2-step group ride flow, billing relative fixtures, and account fallbacks).
However, PUBLIC RELEASE CANDIDATE MUST REMAIN CONDITIONALLY GATED until external hardware, production billing provisioning, and cross-account cloud sync dependencies are validated in staging.